Varanasi the Incomprehensible

by Ekua on March 4, 2011 in India,race/culture/identity

Before I went to India, I knew that I could expect to see an intense religious devotion there; the kind of faith that leads people to make pilgrimages just to plunge themselves in waters that are considered to be sacred. I also knew that I could expect layers of filth. But I hadn’t expected that I would witness the convergence of those two elements in such an unforgettable and disturbing way. Varanasi was the intersection.

Varanasi ended up on my itinerary via Google Maps. Really. As I zoomed out of Kolkata to see what was between it and Agra, Varanasi stood out. The name was familiar so I searched for it online. From what I found, it looked and sounded colorful, and flights from Kolkata to Varanasi were cheap.

I would eventually find out that none of the travel information I’d looked at prior to my arrival adequately described it. After I returned home and looked up Varanasi again, it didn’t take long to find an abundance of non-travel oriented content about some of the disturbing situations I saw there.

I had a pleasant arrival and the Varanasi airport was strangely quiet and clean. I later learned that we’d arrived in a new terminal that had opened just a few days before. The airport pickup I’d arranged was waiting for me when I exited. As we left, the pastoral outskirts we drove through looked pleasant and promising.

The atmosphere changed rapidly as we approached the center of the city and navigated roads that were thick with people, livestock, and rickshaws. We stopped at a strange spot. The guide who had accompanied the driver told me that the car couldn’t go any further. He hopped out and practically ran through the narrow winding alleys of the Old City. I clumsily trailed behind, trying to keep up and avoid both running into cows and stepping in their excrement.

We arrived at the Ganpati Guesthouse, I went to my dumpy room, sighed, and settled in. There were charming parts of this rustic guesthouse, but the room was not good. It was the second worst after the Hotel Diplomat. There was also an open sewer next to the guesthouse that streamed down the hill into the Ganges. I looked down at the murky, trash lined river with a bit of dread about what I’d see happening in it.

In India, if you book train tickets online, it’s not uncommon to be put on a waiting list. People cancel often, so if you’re fairly high on the list, you’re likely to get a spot. I’d booked two waitlisted onward tickets to Agra and now had an official ticket for both. I decided to go with the earlier train that left the following afternoon because I could already tell that I didn’t want to spend more than one night in Varanasi.

As I was fixing my booking, someone approached me. It was the British woman I’d met in Kolkata. She’d just arrived on the train from Darjeeling and was having trouble finding an available room. She had no luck at Ganpati. We chatted before she moved on to try the next hotel. She looked flustered; it was an expression worn by most of the independent traveler friends I ran into more than once on my trip.

I walked down to the river to see the Varanasi sunset scene. I couldn’t take more than a few steps at time without children under the age of 10 trying to sell me boat trips or flower candles or trying to lead me to the silk shop of their “uncle”. There were goats and cows everywhere and of course, sizeable piles of their droppings everywhere. I was ready to call it night, but still felt compelled to walk further along the ghats (the steps leading down to the Ganges).

I reached the Dashashwamedh Ghat. I’m glad I saw it. Hundreds of people had gathered, priests were preparing to perform rituals, and chanting was being played over the loudspeakers. You could tell that it all encompassed the purest of intentions.

Back at my hotel, I had dinner on the roof and watched candles in flowers floating on the river. It’s a pretty thing to see them drift along, but in the end, they just accumulate with the rest of garbage along the shores.  It was about 8pm when I went back to my room. There was not enough reading light in my room, so I sang some songs to entertain myself while showering and getting ready for an early morning. Until some angry fellow guest shouted out, “SHUT UP!” And with that, I decided it was time to go to bed.

I went down to the river before sunrise — before most other tourists, apparently. I was a lone antelope for a pack of little lion sales kids, and they attacked me with sales pitches until I settled on a price with one. He led me to a boat and I got in, naively assuming he’d call over someone who’d actually row the boat. Instead, the little kid himself — who was no more than 8 years old — got in and started rowing. Culture shock #1 of the day.

I thought back to Kolkata when I’d seen a kid on his knees wiping an entire restaurant floor with a rag. The following day I’d seen a joke on MTV India: Q: How do we know that Harry Potter is Indian? A: He’s underage and he has a broom! I wasn’t sure what to make of poking fun at something that I was taught to believe is extremely wrong. And now on this boat, this kid was rowing further away from the shore chatting away in the casual matter-of-fact manner of a seasoned salesman.

It was still almost completely dark when we started. As we made our way down, I could see that we were approaching flames. The boy pointed and said, “Burning Ghats.” Culture shock #2. You know it’s coming, but you don’t realize how exposed it is until you actually see it. Right there on the side of the Ganges, bodies are cremated and their ashes are poured into the river. Corpses that aren’t cremated — like those of pregnant women and children — are wrapped and set out to decompose in the river.

As the sun rose, I began to see the bathing. Culture shock #3. I’d seen the animal feces, the burning bodies, the sewage, and general trash of the Ganges, but none of that could prepare me for actually seeing people submerge themselves in that water. And, as my mouth hung open, those who were bathing in the river stared at me with their mouths agape at the sight of a black woman.

The sun was gorgeous as it rose, filtered by the smoggy air. Silhouettes of birds in flight added to the spectacular image. But I found it hard to reconcile the lovely setting with everything else. There’s a beauty to the act of bathing as a sort of spiritual cleansing, but I couldn’t look past the potential hazards of  it for the people who were in that toxic water and how all the activity was destroying the river.

Growing up in California, and also during my brief childhood stint in Maryland, regardless of religious beliefs, there was always a general understanding that nature is divine; something that provides food for your body and soul. And because of this, I came away with the idea that it should be protected to ensure that it continues to provide life and beauty. There in Varanasi, I got the sense that the idea was that God was inside this natural thing in the world, so you bathe in it so it will protect you and bless you.

I didn’t yet realize that before the invasions of the Mughals and the British, the holiness of the Ganges actually began with a reverence for the river that was not unlike the nature love I grew up with. People began to worship it because it was a giver of life for humans and other animals. The purpose of the cremations taking place along the river was to have people return to the place that gave them life. The Ganges has provided for the growth of and life of one tenth of the world’s population.

As the sun continued to rise, the river became more crowded with tourists in boats and pilgrims and priests in the water. The boy rowing my boat continued to try to sell me anything. He tried to act nonchalant about the rowing, but I could tell he was getting tired. I asked to go back to where we started. I paid him what we’d settled on, plus the same amount more (which was change to me) as a tip. His eyes grew wide as he received the money and ran off.

I decided to walk along the ghats for a bit and saw more and more people were gathering at the edge of the river. Some had even brought their children out for a family dip in the Ganges; the river that sewage and industrial waste flows into; the river of life that’s slowly wasting away with waste. Polluted rivers are a reality of an industrial world, but to see people bathing in and drinking from one, not necessarily out of necessity, but because of religion continued to shock me.

Sometimes the world contracts with travel, sometimes it expands. In Varanasi, it became larger to me. As I left, what I saw there remained unfathomable.

{ 19 comments… read them below or add one }

Sunee March 4, 2011 at 7:06 am

It seems to me that India as a country is one big culture shock. We’ve all heard the stories about the filth and child labour, but somehow it doesn’t become real until you actually see it for yourself, I think. I really enjoyed this post, you managed to make it a little more real for me.

Reply

Ekua March 5, 2011 at 2:49 pm

Nothing really prepares you for actually going there. It was definitely a very different kind of travel experience for me than say, Mexico or Brazil or somewhere else I really enjoyed. But I feel like a more well-rounded traveler after visiting India.

Reply

Andi of My Beautiful Adventures March 4, 2011 at 2:19 pm

You have no idea how jealous I am that you went to Varanasi. I didn’t get to visit when I was in India and I was really sad about that. What a gorgeous narrative you’ve written. Beautiful pics too! I can’t believe someone yelled at you to shut up. Ugh!!!

Reply

Ekua March 5, 2011 at 2:46 pm

Thanks, Andi. Varanasi was very interesting, but to call it overwhelming is an understatement! As far as the singing goes, it wasn’t that late at the time and I thought I sounded good 😛

Reply

Herb March 5, 2011 at 7:10 am

Wow, I think I just cross India off my list.

Reply

Ekua March 5, 2011 at 2:43 pm

Well, India is a huge country. While I am not eager to go back, I would potentially give certain spots another shot and maybe check out Southern India. According to a few people I came across, the south is easier to travel through than Northern India which was where I was.

As far as what I saw in Varanasi, it was very disturbing and I wanted to get out of there as soon as I could, but I wouldn’t go back in time and change my itinerary because you take something away from all experiences!

Reply

HappyHomemakerUK March 7, 2011 at 11:25 am

Your photographs are stunning. So glad to have found your lovely blog 🙂 You may want to join my Expat Linky Party on March 19th.

Reply

Angela March 8, 2011 at 3:45 am

Lovely post. I went to India in February and visited most of the Rajasthan. I didn’t make it to Varanasi and although I know it’s a sacred, and certainly interesting place to see, I’m not sure I’ll want to go.
I admire Indian way to connect with nature, but I strongly doubt I’ll be able to bear the sight of corpses of dead babies floating in the Ganges.
A friend of mine went there a couple of years ago and said she can’t even describe what she felt after seeing them.
I too was pretty shocked by the swarm of little children approaching tourists to sell anything. I know poverty is everywhere, but the level of misery I saw in India, I didn’t see it anywhere else, not even in Brazil almost 20 years ago. All I could think was “India is widely recognized as a world’s (nuclear) power, what on earth is the government doing? If it’s a nuclear power, how is it possible that people in 2011 still live without electricity?”
I truly enjoyed my stay, but there are many aspects of Indian society that I still need to understand. For that, I will go back. I loved the country and the people, but it is obviously not keeping the pace of other developing countries.

Reply

Ekua March 8, 2011 at 9:05 am

Thanks for your thoughtful comment, Angela. I volunteered in a favela in Salvador, Brazil and the poverty there doesn’t even compare with India. There is an exorbitant amount of people who are forgotten or ignored in India, even compared to some of the countries I’ve visited that are poorer than Brazil or India overall.

Once, during a conversation, I referred to India as a 3rd world country and was immediately told that it was 2nd world. I get a sense that in India, amongst people who live well, there is a lot of denial of how awful the living situation is for such a huge portion of the population. I think there is also an unawareness of how it truly compares with countries that might be considered 2nd world. There definitely seems to be a lot of potential for India, but you really can’t deny what you see there now.

Reply

david March 8, 2011 at 4:16 pm

Hi Ekua, I just came across your blog while stumbling around the TBEX website, and I’m so glad that I did. I really enjoyed this post on Varanasi and am looking forward to exploring more of your writing. I’ve never had the desire to go to India and obviously this post isn’t changing that, but maybe one of your other entries will. Anyway, I just wanted to stop and tell you that you have a new fan!

Reply

Ekua March 9, 2011 at 12:27 am

Thanks, David. Glad you like my blog. I’m not sure my posts will change your mind as far as the process of traveling in India goes. Can’t speak for the rest of the country, but if you’re looking for a well-rounded challenge, northern India is perfect. If you want more of a relaxing trip, look elsewhere…

Reply

Odysseus March 13, 2011 at 8:06 pm

Hey, I was reading this post because I was recently in Varanasi and imagine my surprise to find you’d also stayed at the Ganpati! I was one of the people yelling at you to stop singing! (Haha. TOTALLY kidding about the last part — but I really was at the Ganpati in January/February — though I’m just now writing about India on my blog.) Strangely, I also had the experience of running through the streets from the taxi to the hotel, jumping over cow poop on the way. Why don’t they slow down? I’m glad I visited Varanasi for the experience, but truthfully, it was my least favorite Indian city.

I look forward to reading your further adventures in India!

Reply

Odysseus March 13, 2011 at 8:08 pm

Oh, also, did you eat at the rooftop restaurant at the Ganpati? They served my favorite food that I ate the whole time I was in India! My mouth still waters . . .

Reply

Ekua March 13, 2011 at 11:33 pm

My blogging is even more delayed… I was there back at the end of November – early December! Varanasi was my least favorite too… I heard all this bad stuff about Agra, but it really felt mellow there in comparison to Varanasi. But I’m glad I saw it as well.

I did eat on the roof of the Ganpati. It was good, but couldn’t compete with the little cafe in Kolkata that I visited every day during the 6 days I was in that city!

Reply

Rebecca March 14, 2011 at 12:35 am

Holy moly. I can just imagine your shock. I plan to visit India one day… but like others have said, I’m not sure how to really prepare myself.

Reply

Lingeshwaran December 25, 2011 at 9:40 am

Hey, Thanks. Though Am an Indian, I have never been to Varanasi as I live in Southern India. I Must say this is the transparent Post on Varanasi I Have ever Read and heard about.
Now, am planning My trip to Varanasi for the first time. Thanks a Lot. I really like your blog
But, I wish you had a trip to South India Once. Am sure You’d have had a beautiful experience and few Fairy Tale posts too…

Reply

Ekua December 26, 2011 at 9:06 am

Yes, I’ve heard good things about Southern India, but unfortunately I didn’t have time to head down there!

Reply

Paula January 1, 2012 at 10:06 am

I’ve been researching RTW travel for almost a year now and though you are not technically doing the type of travel I’m planning it was great reading your blog because like you I am a black female solo traveler.
I always knew it would be a little more challenging for me so it’s was reaaly good coming across your blog and reading about your travel experiences.

Reply

Ekua January 3, 2012 at 6:31 pm

While traveling solo as a black female can be more challenging, it is not always that way! It varies from place to place. Over the course of my travels, I’ve seen that racism and gender issues are way more prevalent than I’d like to believe. But being black and female has also allowed me to see other sides of places that not all travelers have access to. For example, I can blend in in certain places which can allow me to have more local experiences and get a more real view of a country. Also, I think as a female, you are often viewed as non-threatening which I think overall, makes people more welcoming. Sometimes the hospitality I’ve received in places where I stick out like a sore thumb has been overwhelming in a very positive way!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: